Picture
In case you didn't hear about the latest literary fraud, last week, Jonah Lehrer admitted that he had invented quotes that he attributed to Bob Dylan in his book Imagine: How Creativity Works  Until this literary mischief, he seemed to have a lot going for him--he's a Rhodes scholar, a neuroscientist, and was a staff writer for "The New Yorker."  For whatever reason, he decided his book wouldn't be good enough with manufacturing the quotes he wanted Dylan to have said.

Now, he's resigned from "The New Yorker" and has issued a public apology.  According to the New York Times, Lehrer stated "The lies are over now. . . .  I understand the gravity of my position.  I want to apologize to everyone I have let down, especially my editors and readers."  In my opinion, he should have stopped there.  However, he added: "I will do my best to correct the record and ensure that my misquotations and mistakes are fixed."  Really?  Misquotations?  He makes it sound like he made an innocent mistake, as if the whole thing were a misunderstanding or an innocent accident.

The man who exposed the fraud was a Dylan aficionado, Michael Moynihan; he read Imagine, searched for the source of one of Lehrer's Dylan quotes, and after Lehrer responded to Moynihan's inquiries with several lies, Lehrer ultimately confessed "that he had made it up."  According to Moynihan, "Lehrer had spliced together Dylan quotes from separate published interviews, [and] when the quotes were accurate, he took them well out of context."  Sounds intentional, not a case of mere "misquotation."

An apology from a hoaxer doesn't seem to cut it these days.  Already, Lehrer's publisher, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, has announced that it would recall printed copies of Imagine.  If this hoax becomes anything like James Frey's, it wouldn't be surprising if it results in the issuance of refunds to readers who had bought Imagine thinking if was non-fiction, only to find it was not all it is supposed to be.

It will be interesting to see how this pans out.  His book sales are likely to dwindle (people tend to be less interested in reading non-fiction when it actually isn't true), and it is unclear if he will be able to salvage his writing career.  

The tradition of the literary hoax is alive and well.  And once again, a hoaxer has fooled his publisher, reviewers, and readers before the hoax was revealed.

Works consulted:
"Jonah Lehrer Resigned From New Yorker After Making Up Dylan Quotes for His Book," by Julie Bosman, New York Times, July 30, 2012 (appearing on Media Decoder Blog).

"Due Diligence on Dylan: Writer Found Fraud in First Chapter," by Christine Kearney, Chicago Tribune, Aug. 1, 2012.
 


Comments

11/13/2014 10:42pm

Online learning become a growing trend in the world. Mostly online users love to get online sources which can provide them help in solving their problems. Thanks for sharing this great article to solve students problems who need help about their assignments.

Reply
08/21/2015 5:29am


Loved to read your blog. I would like to suggest you that traffic show most people read blogs on Mondays. So it should encourage blogger to write new write ups over the weekend primarily.
Great post! Interesting information and cute writing style.
Regards

Reply
09/01/2015 3:16am

I feel like getting it reached to everyone through sharing it because I completely enjoyed in this post and thought to viral this information what I got after reading your content. At the last I just to say admin! you carry on this work of providing an interesting information to us.

Reply
09/30/2015 4:35am

You'd think that autobiographies like Imagine: How Creativity Works is a true account of a famous person's life. But authors like Jonah Lehrer don't hesitate to take creative liberties to make their accounts more interesting and captivating to readers. I guess Bob Dylan's life as a musician, philanthropist and father of several children with strange names is not interesting enough. I guess now readers would be intrigued and buy the book or disgusted and leave the book accumulating dust.

Reply
12/02/2015 9:20pm

The good thing is that the person has decided to apologize with everyone & also agreed to correct the records as well.

Reply
12/09/2015 5:58am

Dont lie to me girl because I'am gonna know the truth anyway!

Reply
01/24/2016 2:58am

I also enjoy reading the comments, but notice that a lot of people should stay on topic to try and add value to the original blog post. I would also encourage everyone to bookmark this page to your favorite service to help spread the word. I'll use this information for my essay topics.

Reply
04/29/2016 12:45am

People will probably buy her book but not because of her but because of Bob Dylan. I don't want to judge Jonah Lehrer for I really don't know which side of the story is true but I would want to say that she might be a superstar because of Imagine but people will never forget the issue behind it. So next time, better not to make things made up when what you want to convey is a truth rather than an opinion.

Reply
10/12/2016 6:57am

We offer affprdable essay writing service to suit your needs.

Reply

English-speaking students all over the world can easily find a solution to their essay writing problem, thanks to essay-writing-service.co!

Reply
12/18/2016 9:01pm

SB GAME HACKER APK – DOWNLOAD FOR ANDROID [LATEST VERSION]:
SB Game Hacker Features For Android Devices :
Steps to Download SB Game Hacker Apk:

Reply
12/19/2016 2:26am

Is one of the best tools to download any kind of Apps on your Android tablet and Android phone directly like Games, Wallpaper, Ringtone and Apps.

Reply
01/05/2017 6:36am

Thanks for such a great article here. I was searching for something like this for quite a long time and at last I’ve found it on your blog. It was definitely interesting for me.

Reply
01/12/2017 8:50pm

Zyntix table isn't compromised. if you've been strolling for some time you recognize that out of doors walking isn't always continually viable because of climate Zyntix and different unforeseen circumstances, that is while your treadmill becomes your great pal.
http://guidemesupplements.com/zyntix-review/

Reply
01/15/2017 8:35pm

Nitric Muscle how commonly have you ever began a brand new diet come on now be sincere. if you have been trying to lose weight for some time you've got likely stopped Nitric Muscle and started greater diets than you care to admit.the consequences have a tendency to be the equal.

http://www.strongtesterone.com/nitric-muscle-reviews/

Reply
01/16/2017 11:06pm

Skin Opulent not best will they appearance lovely in your mattress but they'll be comfortable to sleep underneath and they will keep you warm on bloodless nights.you need Skin Opulent to understand that your listing is an asset for the relaxation of your life so long as you stay to make money online.

http://www.skinshining.com/skin-opulent-reviews/

Reply
01/17/2017 8:16pm

Alpha Max No2 the infection therefore strain on the nerve roots additionally can be resolved.oral steroids for sciatica are also administered in more excessive instances. Alpha Max No2 those prescriptions provide ache comfort. but take note that such medications can most effective be used for shorter durations of time only.

http://www.strongtesterone.com/alpha-max-no2-reviews/

Reply
01/18/2017 8:09pm

Alpha Max No2 this schooling is specially crucial for those patients who're fearful about chiropractic remedy.on most first visits chiropractors will deliver the patient Alpha Max No2 their first chiropractic adjustment or manipulation. the manipulation can be the primary of many for the.

http://t-rexmuscleadvice.com/alpha-max-no2/

Reply
01/19/2017 8:31pm

Alpha Monster Advanced bodybuilders began their training at a younger age teenage bodybuilding poses lots of dangers. teenage bodies aren't completely evolved even Alpha Monster Advanced after puberty girls and boys have to still revel in a length of increase earlier than they're surely physically adults.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/alpha-monster-advanced/

Reply

MP 10th Class Board Examinations

Reply
01/20/2017 8:15pm

HL Slim Pro you will get is a yelp and at the worst you would possibly sprain its tail.chihuahua is very tough puppies being capable of take lots of bodily activity. HL Slim Pro also chihuahua is virtually excitable and their first response is to bite if they get anxious or stunned.

http://greentheorygarcinia.com/hl-slim-pro/

Reply
01/22/2017 9:33pm

Testo Xtreme enriched with usual components is a best choice of weight gaining supplement for men of all a while. http://musclesciencefacts.com/testo-xtreme/

Reply
01/23/2017 8:08pm

Alpha Prime Elite it'll occur pretty and could sense insufferable. it will accentuate with the passage of some hours. this symptom may be followed by means of nausea vomiting Alpha Prime Elite diarrhea or constipation fever abdominal swelling and so forth.typically regularly commonly.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/alpha-prime-elite/

Reply
01/23/2017 11:51pm

I need to apologize to everybody I have let down, particularly my editors and perusers." In my feeling, he ought to have halted there.

Reply
01/24/2017 8:12pm

Raw Power XL the belief that lifting dumbbells will cause them to hypertrophy beyond recognition. the most common solution you may even hear is oh i don't want to raise Raw Power XL weights because i don't need to grow large muscle tissues.this is a delusion that has been circulating.

http://www.strongtesterone.com/raw-power-xl/

Reply
01/25/2017 8:11pm

Reaction Male Enhancement bread whilst cooking is it now not also a possibility that it may also amplify a prostrate gland this is the reason why guys with lively intercourse Reaction Male Enhancement lifestyles are more affected by prostrate illnesses like prostate cancer than young males. yeast will essentially travel up.

http://www.strongtesterone.com/reaction-male-enhancement/

Reply
01/26/2017 8:19pm

Stack Xtreme a lot of shock instances of debt’ then you could need to understand approximately how first-rate to settle any debts you have got.as we've got all come to examine Stack Xtreme most debts end up with a letter of summons correctly requiring you to repay a debt plus notifying.

http://guidemesupplements.com/stack-xtreme-reviews/

Reply
01/27/2017 8:11pm

Platinum XT 1000 whether it is your food selections your emotional nation or you do not know what a right component size is you could make adjustments in order to lower your Platinum XT 1000 weight and growth your lifespan.component length and understanding precisely.

http://t-rexmuscleadvice.com/platinum-xt-1000/

Reply
01/29/2017 9:59pm

Jack Hammer XL make certain your plastic health care professional realize approximately it. herbal breast enhancement tablets cream & formulas can virtually work presenting is Jack Hammer XL used nicely.it's without a doubt a very good concept to probe a bit deeper into the concern of breast-expansion.

http://musclegainfast.com/jack-hammer-xl/

Reply
01/30/2017 8:18pm

Testomenix proportionate 30 mg testosterone proportionate 60 mg testosterone reciprocate 60mg and testosterone decapitate a hundred mg. the mixture of the testosterone Testomenix are time-released to provide an immediate impact whilst nevertheless final energetic.

http://www.strongtesterone.com/testomenix/

Reply
01/31/2017 8:12pm

Stack Xtreme absolutely crave protein and when you eat protein then your frame breaks up the protein into amino acids which then assist your muscle mass to grow and while Stack Xtreme your muscle tissue as soon as were fats and now they're turning into muscle then you are getting rid of the fats.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/stack-xtreme/

Reply
02/03/2017 10:18pm

framaroot apk

Reply
04/03/2017 10:37pm

jac 10th results

Reply
04/03/2017 11:28pm

According to reports from the KSEEB board which was released by Minister in Karnataka State Kimmane Rathnakar, 79.16% students have cleared the examination.

Karnataka 10th class sslc results 2017

Reply
05/01/2017 12:03am

ssc results 2017 10th class

Reply
05/08/2017 4:28am

The leather is always in fashion, especially in winters. Coz we have to wear stylish stuff so we can go with stylish leather jackets.<a href="http://www.famousmoviejackets.com/39/movie-leather-jackets">Movie Jackets</a> Amazing design and stylish stuff i liked it a lot. I have known some of these kinda websites which provide <a href="http://www.famousmoviejackets.com/38/celebrity-jackets">Celebrity Jackets</a> as well, I gifted one to my boyfriend and he loved it.

Reply
05/22/2017 4:16am


Welcome to canada post tracking Track Canada Post Couriers & Parcels By Entering the Canada Post Tracking Number

Reply
05/27/2017 4:48am

This open source, the cross-platform multimedia player plays most files and helps in major streaming protocols

Reply
06/06/2017 6:05am

It's a really like music. He is asking her to lay down with him. Your best bet is to go study the lines...you're not the only one to have 'trouble' knowing some of Dylan's performing, but you won't have an issue with his lines (I hope). :)

Reply
06/15/2017 11:15pm

If you want to access your router fill in 168.192.1.1 in the address bar of your browser

Reply
07/22/2017 8:30am

good your mobile information use in check.State you're out as well as Fildo App – Best Music Streaming App for Android After importing your library of tunes, you'll wish to make certain nice.
<a href="https://fildoappdownload.com/">https://fildoappdownload.com/…apk-download</a>

Reply
07/22/2017 8:31am


Click here to get
<a href="http://aptoideappdownload.com/2016/07/aptoide-vs-google-playstore-best.html">aptoide Alternative</a>

Reply
07/29/2017 9:09am

NICE POST...<a href="https://teatvappdownload.com/">Tea TV</a>

Reply
08/07/2017 7:09am

It depends on on the type of properly secured. Only someone that knows what they are doing can break a properly secured.

Reply
09/13/2017 6:21pm

Thanks for the great Post. Loved the comments.
<a href="https://uktvnowapks.com/">UktvNow Apk</a>

Reply
09/25/2017 12:22pm

This is truly an practical and pleasant information for all. Thanks for sharing this to us and more power

Reply
10/03/2017 12:37am

Mmm.. good to be here in your article or post, whatever, I think I should also work hard for my own website like I see some good and updated working in your site.

Reply
10/03/2017 5:25am

so happy to find good place to many here in the post, the writing is just great, thanks for the post.

Reply

You re in point of fact a just right webmaster. The website loading speed is amazing. It kind of feels that you're doing any distinctive trick. Moreover, The contents are masterpiece. you have done a fantastic activity on this subject!

Reply



Leave a Reply